Fallible Memory

For most of my life I’ve kept a journal. Starting at age 12, when I had a “Dear Diary,” book, I started writing what seemed important in my life. I think they were meant for girls to write about their crushes on boys, but, being a serious child, I recorded my fears about the Cuban missile crisis.

I kept writing into my college years and after, although not regularly because I was busy with classes and then work. But now when I go back and read more than (sometime sporadic) 60 years of journal-keeping, I have to question my memory. Either I’ve forgotten much or I’ve gotten it wrong. What if I didn’t have this journal to remind me of what really happened, so that my memories would be selective, and I would remember only the good and not the bad—or vice versa?

Even my brothers and sisters (seven of us, total) have different recollections of events we experienced together—Christmas day, visiting grandparents, trips to the family cottage, where I only remember sunny days when clearly the summer weather in Wisconsin includes a lot of rainy days. But does it matter? Maybe being happy is more important.

My friend, Evelyn, 92, remembers very little, including her age, imagining that she’s sometime in her 60s. What she doesn’t remember she unknowingly makes up. When I visited her recently at her memory care place, she was sitting in front of an iPad that endlessly cycled through family photos. When I asked about the people in the photos, she told me stories that I know to be wrong. She told me her granddaughter’s name, which was close but not quite right.  She thought her son had two daughters when he only has one, and that those two daughters produced grandchildren who were lovely and smart. Do we make up stories that make us proud of our family?

She told me that the food in her nursing home was delicious and that she and her fellow residents just “gobbled it up,” and yet at our previous meeting she said she never went down for dinner, and that staff brought the food up. But how much more fun to imagine enjoying a tasty dinner with your fellow residents.

Her son, who lives a thousand miles away, calls her every day, she said. I have no doubt that he cares for her, but I doubt that Mark, who has a busy working life, calls every day. But isn’t it better to make up these loving stories than to complain that you never hear from your son and that your granddaughter is failing in school. I remember my mother made her life miserable because her children didn’t visit or call enough to satisfy her need for attention.

Maybe our memories reflect our personalities: is the glass half empty or half full? Maybe it’s better to make up memories when we’re not sure.

But Evelyn seems happy, lost in her world of successful granddaughters and a loving son. My father, too, didn’t seem bothered by his loss of memory. Starting in his 80s, he couldn’t remember the names of friends, relatives or the orders doled out by my mother: “Paul, I told you an hour ago to take out the garbage.”

Yet he maintained his joy in life. He loved gardening, but it wasn’t until his 90s that he stopped planting, because he realized he was forgetting to water the tomatoes and basil. Even with a bad memory, he could sing, play the piano and take part in an all-harmonica band until he had a stroke at 94. When he forgot that my mother told him that their granddaughter would be visiting later, he was delighted and surprised an hour later when she knocked on the door.

My dad, who loved ice cream, also loved talking to strangers we met on our walks, even if he couldn’t remember the conversation hours later. Can we still enjoy having ice cream if we can’t remember what we did the day before?

Is it necessary to remember correctly every aspect of our lives? What if we’re just happy, no matter what we remember? Are our delusions wrong? I don’t know, but I think about memory a lot, especially since mine seems to be gradually slipping. I remember a dentist telling me once he had “photographic” memory, but it didn’t make him happy because he could never erase incidents he would rather forget.

When Evelyn and I met, we talked for half hour, my old friend telling her own version of stories, while I listened and told her my own stories. Who knows what was accurate? We were just happy being with each other, old friends who worked together decades ago, remembering our favorite versions of our lives.

The Shame of Aging

A few years ago, I overheard a real estate agent telling a prospective buyer of the house next door that the tall bushes along our fence must be there because the owners (us) either must like their privacy or they were old and couldn’t keep up.

For some reason, this comment stung. I do like my privacy, yes, but I had to check myself: Had I let things go?  Were neighbors noticing our somewhat unkempt yard, which I preferred to lawns partly because I wanted to preserve some small bit of land for insects, birds and other creatures? But, in a subdivision of mostly neat lawns, were my neighbors gossiping about the old ladies on the block who couldn’t keep it together?

I stopped thinking about this incident until I was recently visiting a relative in her 40s. She and her family had moved into an older neighborhood where most of the original homes were small, maybe 1,000 square feet at most, the kind that were perfectly adequate when my generation, born in the 1950s, was younger. But a new generation wanted bigger houses for their families—I don’t blame them—and was either replacing the smaller houses with bigger ones or adding a second floor. My young relative complained that a lot of the people on the block weren’t renovating their houses but were letting them go, which was bringing down the property values for the whole neighborhood.

Of course, without her saying so, I knew that the people who were content with their plain old small brick houses were my generation, who didn’t need anything bigger or fancier. They had raised their children, who were now gone, and wanted nothing more than their small houses and gardens. Even though my cousin complained about this innocently, not even thinking, I’m sure, that I was one of those old people, I had to cringe.

Yet our yard and house are nowhere near as bad as the older neighbors down the street whose belongings spill out from the garage and whose two decrepit cars are stuffed. There’s no question they are hoarders, but I wonder if young people in the neighborhood think this is what happens when you get old. Of course, the younger generations grew up with computers, where most of their life is stored, so they don’t have old letters, vacation photos, records and DVDs or stereo systems taking up so much physical space.

While I have too much stuff, I don’t have enough memory, which is embarrassing when you’re standing in front of the car service guy and trying to remember the name of your car part that needs replacing. I routinely find myself in situations where store clerks, waiters and medical staff slowly explain things to me, not without some condescension. Or am I feeling shame because I can’t figure out how the self-serve coffee machine in my doctor’s office works?

I was recently at a doctor’s appointment and the young physician’s assistant suggested two procedures that would help my condition. When I went to make an appointment for one of them, I confused one procedure with the other, and the receptionist (but that’s not what they call them, is it?) questioned me. To straighten it out, the PA came out and assured the receptionist that she was right. Did I notice a glance pass between them? —another confused old person?

Recently I took part in a webinar with both younger and older people. One older woman kept interrupting the proceedings because was she having trouble with Zoom. I cringed, not only ashamed for my generation that doesn’t understand technology, but also for this woman’s obliviousness at hogging the proceedings.  

Maybe the worst is our shame about our physical deterioration—wrinkles, balding or gray hair, the canes we use to hold ourselves steady, our stooped bodies, drapes on our arms, or how we sometimes struggle to get up from the chair. How do we fight that judgment in a society that values youth, beauty and physical strength? I recently read that teenage girls (!) are getting Botox, already trying at that young age to have perfect faces. It seems the standard of beauty keeps getting higher.

So how do we seniors even try to keep up? We dye our hair, work out at the gym, get surgery to remove wrinkles, and wear tight jeans so someone might possibly mistake us for a 25-year-old.  Are we accepting society’s shame? Are we disgusted by our bodies and of what they will become? We fear ending up in nursing homes, where there’s a smell of decay—of bodies that can no longer move and can’t take care of themselves—that can be sickening. Maybe that’s why some older folks work hard to make sure their houses are clean and neat, no dirt behind the fridge, no bad smells.

The other day I crossed paths with a younger man, maybe in his 30s, who was jogging. I looked at him with wonder and envy—that he could lift his legs so high without pain and move so effortlessly. Yet I can’t help but feel that, in my older years, I have one leg up on him.  I don’t know this man, but I know it takes a long time to acquire what I have—more understanding and compassion for myself and the world; and the useful ability to not take myself too seriously. He may be physically stronger, but decades of hard knocks have made my heart emotionally sturdy.

The Perils of Memory

I was recently on a trip with a friend who wanted to show me his favorite places in his home state, some of which he hadn’t visited for 20-30 years. But when we arrived at these treasured places, they didn’t quite match his memory. One place that he remembered as having several trails had none. A car route he remembered as particularly picturesque proved to be nothing special. A river he remembered crossing easily was now impassable.

I’ve had these experiences myself, especially as I get older, and it makes me not trust my memory. I have to wonder if we selectively remember certain things about a place we visit and forget other attributes, so when we revisit it years later we have to combine our faulty memories with the reality in front of us. Putting together these disparate views can be disorienting.

Or maybe our brain combines different places into one, taking the best of each place and creating someplace that, over time, becomes burnished in our memory as the perfect place. It’s that place we want to return to over and over again, the one we mentally escape to when life gets tough and we’re looking for a refuge.

Continue reading “The Perils of Memory”

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑